Now is the primal day

Bear at a campsite
Bear Among the Tents by Liz Shine

I’m thinking lately about communities I’ve been part of as a writer because this is perhaps the most necessary and difficult part of the work. I’ve often heard described the feeling I know well after having immediately written a thing: a poem, a piece of prose—anything! That rush of feeling: it must be genius, it must have come out whole and perfect. This feeling comes despite all of our knowing that this is never how it goes, that the thing becomes whole and perfect only after you have visited it with a clear mind again and again and again.

As a young writer, I flocked to generative groups, mostly as a means to verify (to myself) the identity I craved so much: writer. We gathered in booths at coffee shops and wrote, sometimes collaboratively. We swapped books that had made us swoon, perplexed us, made us believe. We read our works aloud to each other, always with the unspoken question running in the background: Is this any good?

With practice, we all got better, but that question (Is this any good?) rather inconveniently never goes away. It makes it hard to keep gathering in groups, keep bringing pages to other writers to be “critiqued”. Some of my experiences in these sorts of groups have left me wanting to retreat back into the comfortable space where I write, and it feels good. But those groups have been the minority.

I’ve been in critique groups for thirty years, and while it can be a painful experience to bring my pages and leave with new awareness of where my writing didn’t quite come through the way I hoped it would, those helpful writers are my first and most generous readers. They will actually read it and try to help you make it better. That’s a gift of time and attention I am lucky to have.

I’m in a lot of groups now, and I sometimes feel like the demands of the clock might stretch me to the breaking point like a bar of taffy about to become two. I’m in two accountability groups (one virtual and one in person), two critique groups, and one generative poetry group. And that’s not even counting the two book groups, which are also part of building my craft.

It’s not just that you need others to help you see the parts of your work that sag and slack and snore. It’s also that you need others who are going through the same periods of doubt and shame and who can remind you when you get too engulfed in the parts of this work that are struggle that the only way out is through, and none of what you are feeling is unique to you. These groups give us the chance to sometimes be the encourager and sometimes be the person standing at the edge, both of these roles having a symbiotic relationship in which both are strengthened.

Shoutout to my current and past writing groups, including the accountability group I’m working with over at the new Olympia writing community hub for classes and connection, OlyPages, my weekly fiction critique group, the groups I’m part of over at Inked Voices, and my group of educator/writers who meet quarterly at each other’s houses for dinner and critique. I also frequently exchange pages over email with writers I meet in those groups. And I have no regrets. It is time well spent. In giving feedback, so much vicarious learning happens.

The title of this month’s newsletter comes from the following poem by Nan Shepherd. When I read it, I thought: this is the creative process! And thank goodness we are not alone. Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when published

from In the Cairngorms
VII

Strange gifts of pleasure has the mind, 
Strange darknesses the soul.
An influence takes her from the blind
Dark worlds that round her roll—

The world of rocks and streaming seas, 
and thrusting tangled roots; 
Of bogs and old engulfed trees,
And boulders dank as brutes. 

And sunken there the mind may not
Relume her former fire,
All ther bright pinnacles forgot, 
Her vehemence and ire. 

Down and down and further down, 
Deformed, annulled, unmade,
She feels the whole creation drowm, 
The ache of form allayed. 

The streaming seas, the ocean gulf, 
The rocks, dissolve away. 
Now she may re-create herself. 
Now is the primal day. 

Small Things That Have Been Bringing Me Joy

  • Walking. This has been part of my creative practice and my spiritual health since I was a teen, walking back and forth across my small, soggy town
  • Waking before everyone else (except Honey, the dog) to write. Getting into that flow.
  • Doing yoga at home
  • Running one of my usual routes and stopping to practice handstands at the park
  • Reading and commenting on all the poems in my generative poetry group

Found Sentences from What I’ve Been Reading

“When we allow our characters to make mistakes, we release them from the grip of our own authorial narcissism.” From “Dysfunctional Narratives” by Charles Baxter


Books I Read in October (One sentence review)

Hello Beatuiful by Ann Napolitano: Cool parallels with Little Women and other literary allusions and made me cry (in a good way).

Triage by Claudia Rankine: Thank goodness I also had the SAL talk to make up for some of my struggles in another brilliant beyond me hybrid work from Rankine.

The Singer’s Gun by Emily St John Mandel: Chekhov’s cat and his gun, and this book was a page-turning delight!

Jellyfish Have No Ears by Adele Rosenfeld (translater: Jeffrey Zuckerman): Handed to me by a student and finished in a day, this book is immersive, a trip for the senses, and explores the experience of a mostly deaf woman.

Whidbey by T Kira Madden : Shifting perspectives (some of them difficult to empathize with) mystery that comes with a sexual abuse trigger warning.

Imperfect Thirst by Galway Kinnell: Done already? Should I start again? So many delightful and clever poems in this collection, a couple that might have been written on a dare to write a beautiful poem about something gross.

Mosquitoes by William Faulkner: Some artists on a boat ride from New Orleans eating grapefruit and acting foolish—fun and full of fun sentences.


A Writing Prompt for November

Write a letter or an email to a writing friend about some of the things you’ve been working on/thinking about. Ask them to write back.


October/November Goals Goals

  • Follow my writing contract at least 80/20
  • 40,000 wc on my WIP by 11/30
  • Three submissions per week every Sunday

Reflection Question for Your Creative Practice

How could you show up more for your writing community?


I also work as a writing coach and love helping writers gain confidence, set goals, and develop their work. I was a writer first, but I’ve been teaching now for over twenty-five years. Coaching weaves those two skill sets in a way that I love, love, love. I work with writers locally and over Zoom. For more information on coaching, email me at eatyourwords.lizshine@gmail.com or see my website.

You can see my books here and read some of my short works here.

Looking for any of the books I’ve mentioned here? Order through my Bookshop.org affiliate page to support me and my local bookstore!

Liz Shine teaches high school English, writes, edits, and coaches other writers from her home in Olympia, WA. When she begins to feel overwhelmed by it all, she simply looks up at Mount Rainier in the distance and gets back to work. If that fails, she heads to the ocean. She is a founding editor at Red Dress Press. Her Substack Make Time is her gift to writers, like her, trying to magic time in this crazy, busy world. All of those posts are cross-posted on the blog here. You can see more of her writing at lizshine.com and find her on Instagram {@lizshine.writer} cooking, traveling, and in other ways seeking moments of awe. She has been an active participant in communities of writers since the early 1990s. She’s learned that two things feel truly purpose-driven in life: writing and coaching other writers. In the in between (because one cannot be driving for a purpose every moment), she enjoys looking for wonder and connection. She is a lifelong yoga student, an enthusiastic walker along streets and trails, and an amateur gardener and vegetarian cook. She lives in Olympia, WA. She believes in the power of practice and has been practicing writing since some time in the early 90s when she became an adult in the rain-soaked city of Aberdeen. Writing began with journaling, as a way to understand a confusing, sometimes violent coming-of-age. She writes mostly fiction, some nonfiction, and poetry, and holds an MFA from Pacific Lutheran University’s Rainier Writers Workshop. She is a founding editor at Red Dress Press.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *